Compliments of the season. We are solicitors to Mr. Kelvin Keshi and write on his behalf. In view of the unbalanced report of City People Magazine not verifying information before publishing, in disregard of some of the sacrosanct principles of journalism of balance, fairness and objectivity, we hereby state our client's case.
Background:
Kelvin Keshi, who my office represents, was a staff of Genevieve
Magazine. He joined the company in 2008 as a Staff Writer, rose to the
position of Senior Staff Writer and later rose to the position of
Assistant Features Editor. In April, 2013, a former staff of Genevieve
Magazine, one Isaac Oladipupo recommended Kelvin Keshi to Lanre Nzeribe,
MD of Lantana International Lltd. Lanre said his Company wants to go
into lifestyle publication
and wanted Kelvin to resign and be the editor of the magazine. Kelvin
resigned in April, 2013, did the foundational work, including
recruitment of staff and gave general editorial direction to the
proposed magazine.
On the 3rd of
June, 2013, Lantana International Ltd, through Lanre Nzeribe issued him
a three months provisional employment and unilaterally changed the
agreed negotiation to Assistant Editor. He had also deliberately delayed
the appointment letter until Kelvin had started work to reduce the
chances of rejection of the offer, which was a breach of their verbal
agreement. In trying to cover up his gimmick and betrayal of trust, he
promised to make the employment permanent after three months.
But
in the second month Lantana International, publishers of Monalisa
Magazine started owing salary and after extracting enough editorial
contents from Kelvin Keshi, announced to workers that the magazine was
suspending its editorial unit. That was late August. Two months’ salary
was owed as at this time. No termination was made. Kelvin demanded for
his salary arrears and the company made payment of July salary with a
promise that August salary will be paid later. Monalisa and Lanre then
cut off communication with him, consequent on him going online to report
the injustice meted out on him by the company.
Monalisa
and Lanre, in particular felt offended and using Monalisa as a front as
usual, wrote a letter to the Lagos state police command, alleging that
Kelvin stole the company’s identity card, flash
drive, internet modem and laptop (the laptop Kelvin uses belongs to him
and was bought by him with proof of receipts). It was obviously a
crooked and calculated ploy to turn the disagreement between both
parties on its head and make it appear as a criminal matter so he could
involve the police to harass Kelvin.
He
reported, and one DSP Thompson, whose action and body language portray a
man that has been bought by the ‘couple’ called Monalisa and Lanre ‘my
clients.’ He declared Kelvin guilty while investigation was still
on-going, ordered him to be detained for over 36 hours. As a condition
for his release and payment of his August salary arrears, the said DSP
Thompson instructed retraction of the publication, return of the company
identity card, internet modem and flash drive. All the
conditions were met. But Lanre Nzeribe and Monalisa vowed that the
salary will not be paid. They kept instigating the police to arrest and
charge Kelvin to court for a matter that police have no business with.
IF THERE WAS NO TERMINATION, KELVIN CANNOT BE SAID TO HAVE STOLEN
IDENTITY CARD, MODEM AND FLASH DRIVE THAT WERE GIVEN TO HIM BY THE
COMPANY.
What
was done was suspension of the editorial department and not termination
of his employment. Monalisa and Lanre also doctored his C.V and claimed
that Kelvin lied that he was the Editor of Genevieve Magazine before he
joined them. Kelvin has never lied about his qualifications or
experience; he lets his work do the rest for him. And why would Monalisa
lie so brazenly and hollowly just to cover her guilt tracks? What
reason does Kelvin have to lie about his qualifications or CV?
Genevieve Magazine’s staff list and the corresponding position is
published on the team list page in every edition. The publisher of
Genevieve Magazine is her friend and adopted mentor, so DID THEY (she
and Lanre) NOT MAKE THEIR INDEPENDENT FINDINGS BEFORE EMPLOYING HIM?
Lanre
and Monalisa also doctored the employment letter as published by City
People Magazine when they removed the name of LANTANA INTERNATIONAL LTD
and published an employment letter without a letterhead. WHAT IS LANRE
NZERIBE HIDDING? IS LANTANA INTERNATIONAL LICENSED TO GO INTO
PUBLISHING?
In view of the fact that the police is delving into a pure civil matter and the failure of the police to act on our petition of
22nd October, 2013 to the Commissioner of Police, Lagos
State, against the actions, conduct and utterances of DSP Thompson,
leader of the investigating team, we went to court for the court to
determine if the matter is a civil matter or a criminal matter and
whether suspension is the same thing as termination. The matter comes up
on the 16th of January, 2014.
Monalisa
also granted and interview to City People last week where she alleged
amongst other that Kelvin Keshi is not a qualified journalist. While we
will address the defamatory angle next year at the high court, we want
to also make clear some facts in response to Monalisa’s malicious but
comical and empty lies in the said interview.
Kelvin
has a degree (HND) in Mass Communication from the Federal Polytechnic,
Auchi; and has distinguished himself in his field of expertise since his
undergraduate days. While at school, he was the editor of a campus
magazine. At the NYSC camp after graduation in Obubra, Cross River
State; he was the Editor-in-Chief of the Orientation Broadcasting
Service (OBS). With an excellent track record at the camp, the NYSC
state secretariat ensured he was posted to the Cross River Broadcasting
Service (CRBC), Calabar strictly on merit. He was the President of the
Publicity CDS Group and Editor-in-Chief of the NYSC Passing Out
magazine.
On
completion of NYSC, Kelvin worked as Reporter/Researcher with the News
Magazine;was Editor of Genexx Magazine; and was Staff Writer, Senior
Staff Writer and Assistant
Features Editor at Genevieve Magazine in less than three years. He has authored two novelettes, Bukky and Friends; and Agu, the son of the gods –
which are both highly rated and gradually making inroads in the
literature market. So what qualifications was Monalisa talking about?
Lastly,
she made an amusing claim when she said they ‘helped’ Kelvin by hiring
him. That was the height of clannishness. On the contrary, it was Kelvin
who ACTUALLY did Lanre and Monalisa a huge favour by agreeing to lend
his knowledge, skills and experience to them in laying the foundation of
the place. Kelvin insists Lanre and Monalisa had no clue about how to
achieve what they wanted until he gave the blueprint, editorially and
administratively.
Monalisa
Chinda ordinarily ought to be a role model to her 'fans.' Why would
she delve into fabrication of documents, criminal distortion of truth by
giving police false information, and defaming on the pages of the media
the reputation and integrity of a well qualified journalist by calling
him half-baked and unqualified? The courts will decide.
Let us also state here that with regard to the ‘office romance’ Monalisa kept harping on in her desperate attempt to clean up her mess, the lady in question was only a colleague and is still a friend of Kelvin Keshi. Kelvin has a fiancée who is also a close friend of the lady. That is where it ends. Monalisa attempts on this are too tame and inconsequential. No need to dissipate further energy on this point.
Monalisa, who has been silent on the issue recently granted City People magazine an interview where she cleared the air on what really happened. What she said below...
The case was a very sad one. Kelvin as a matter of fact was a mistake. He is boy we tried to help even though we knew deep down he wasn't well qualified but we needed to get someone who has expreience because other staff are fresh graduates. So we just told him to come on board and when he came, he had his CV doctored, his address doctored and he said he was the assistant editor in that publication but he wasnt. He lied about so many things that we didn't feel was necessary for him to have lied about.
He was good at writing and so we said as long as you are good at writing, its not a problem because we need a very good person who can head the editorial department. His disposition was very laid back but we said come on board, we need people to be groomed. Well he came on board but started having an affair in the office. We didn't realize he was having an affair with the same lady in the other publication house where they came from. He came down here and started off from where he left off. I didn't know and there was so much commotion going on. He couldn't head his department nor meet his targets, and in the midst of all that, there was another girl working with them who they also frustrated. So we told him to go away for a while, we didn't even lay him off and the next was that he went on crazy on the internet, He started publishing company intellectual property. So we had to change a whole lot of thing. We had to change the title of the magazine, some text and lots more. To our utter disappointment, he has a brother who is a lawyer so he came and we had a meeting with them and he was totally disappointed. He said this was just a disgruntled brother who feels he wasn't treated well. I said how because we were always talking on the phone and i kept asking him what the problem was. It was much later after we laid him off we realized this affair he was having was affecting him. That was just what happened".
When asked if he was owed any salary as Kelvin alleged, Monalisa said
"We have documents to prove there is nothing like that. all the while he was meant to meet up his target but he was concentrating on his job and we asked him to go away for two weeks. Perhaps its the two weeks pay he is asking of and that is not done anywhere, you cant go and release company property just like that, its not done. I pray wherever he is right now, may God forgive him".
Monalisa Chinda’s and Lanre Nzeribe’s marriage of inconvenience, By Kelvin Keshi
It was Tuesday August 27 and another lifeless day filled with uncertainties, inconsistencies and a shameful lack of direction at Monalisa, the white elephant magazine misadventure of Lanre Nzeribe and Monalisa Chinda. Lisa had suddenly gone AWOL for close to a month from her ceremonial publisher’s seat, staff were being owed two months’ salary and Lanre was stalling. He rarely showed up in the office and whenever he did, he barely spoke with anyone before he would zoom off again in his black Maserati. Outside, he was always conscious to give off a deceptive public image of the hip ‘big boy’ and perfect gentleman to camouflage his real insensitive, aloof and condescending sides.
Back
to the farce at 19 Ademola Adetokunbo Street, Victoria Island (Chase Mall). After
their publicised breakup, there were whispers Lisa had reconciled with Lanre
and was coming back to her ceremonial seat. The ‘news’ cheered up some of the
junior staff. It wasn’t surprising
because to some degree, she was the life of the party in the company with her
chirpy, free-spirited, girl-next-door, almost simpleton nature. Some of the
workers wanted to buy coloured cardboard and decorative materials and another
one got external speakers from outside the office. The driver had angrily left
the company two weeks earlier because he said Lanre paid him N25, 000 as salary
instead of N40, 000 they had agreed, so I offered to drive them to the store.
While
waiting at the park of the megastore, I glanced at my wristwatch. It was 3pm.
The ‘party’ was ready, but no word yet from the ‘red carpet’ guest. I decided
to call her.
“Hello
Keshi, what’s happening in the office?”
she asked.
“Nothing,
really,” I replied and hesitated to gauge her mood. “…just that some of the
staff are excited you’re coming back and are planning a small welcome for you.”
“Oh,
no ooo. Who said I’m coming back? I’m not ooo. I’m not talking with Lanre. I
don’t know what they’re talking about,” she answered tongue-in-cheek.
A fading façade
Let
me pause here and introduce myself. My
name is Kelvin Keshi (pictured above) and, until Thursday August 29, was the Assistant Editor of
Monalisa
Magazine. Lisa and Lanre had hired me sometime in April, on the
recommendation of a mutual friend, to help set up a trendy lifestyle magazine
that would in no time set the pace in its genre. Even though it was an onerous
task, I was set for the challenge and knew I could draw from my skills and
experience to deliver on their request. I earnestly set off for work, most of
the time multi-tasking as editor, administrative and human resources manager
and working late into the night. Incidentally, I had another offer from an Abuja-based company to be an Assistant
Editor and Lagos bureau chief of a political magazine but I turned it down on
the excuse that I just got engaged with a similar job and wanted to give it 100
percent.
I
remember the several meetings I had with Lanre, Lisa and the mutual friend –
sometimes lasting till 10:30 pm – to discuss and deliberate on issues like
editorial thrust, philosophy, mission, vision, target demography, templates,
sectionalisation, themes, pagination, story ideas, online presence, USPs,
advert generation, circulation and distribution and staffing for the magazine.
In all of these sessions I noticed almost everyone else was shallow about what
they really wanted; but after much prodding, Lisa said she‘d like a lifestyle
magazine with a mass appeal. Truth is, they were largely vague about the new
magazine concept, but I still tried to decrypt their nebulous ideas,
concretised, gave life and substance, documented and presented to them.
But
as it would appear eventually, that was all Lanre wanted from me: to use me to
set up the magazine and then whip up and amplify inexistent and inconsequential
issues along the way as convenient alibis to sever the working relationship. I
first suspected when he issued three-month temporary employment to the first
batch of staff and arbitrarily fixed salaries without giving room for negotiations.
When I questioned it, he said salaries would be reviewed upwardly at the end of
the three months and permanent employment letters issued. Lies!
Also
in breach of initial discussions before I agreed to resign a job and join him,
he affixed the title ‘Assistant Editor’ to my name instead of ‘Editor.’
Curiously, after all editorial work had been concluded, he introduced his
sister, Ejine, as ‘Editor’ and requested me to forward all edited materials to
her. Another devious stunt by Lanre to sell and credit my intellectual work to
someone else. Ingenious! This is the true Lanre. (You’ll wonder why this guy
cannot maintain five seconds of eye contact. Psychologists, go figure. And no,
he isn’t shy). It was the same
manipulative ploy he used against the first Fashion Editor, Margaret that
forced her to resign angrily after he paid her N50, 000 less than the agreed
sum on the sly excuse that she didn’t write enough articles. Amusingly, his
current ‘Fashion Editor’ and ‘Creative Director’ cannot boast of a single story
in the magazine!
I
only fear for some people. But I guess the saying ‘once bitten, twice shy’
doesn’t ring a bell for everyone. Ejine never showed up in the office once and
her editing via e-mails was just so-so, forcing me to re-edit again.
Lanre
also asked that since stories for the first edition were completed, my team and
I should write for subsequent editions which I obliged him out of trust. As I
discovered later, his wily game plan was to get as much intellectual and
editorial contents out of me for subsequent editions before he schemes me out
of the set-up. (Round of applause dude, but like the Warri man would say, ‘Lanre, this time, u don dive rock.’).
He who pays the piper…
The
next day, Lisa was back in the office and to her glorified seat after a month
forced hiatus. Lanre too was there, as happy as a lark – or more fittingly,
like a little boy whose stolen toy had just been found. They wanted to meet
separately with some staff members over some petty non-work related issues
Lanre had deliberately sensationalised with willing pawns to create distractions
and play out his script of getting rid of me after I’d created a working
structure for him.
Lanre repeated those same trivial lines -
about some staff having tiffs, being emotionally attached to each other and
some people not working enough. …The same worn-out quibbles he had rehashed
over and over again and magnified as excuse also not to pay salaries. For the
benefit of doubt, all editorial assignments for the first issue had been
completed, edited and designed on the template and he had no complaints about
that. In assigning stories, editing them or relating with my team, I operated
with a spirit of fairness, objectivity and balance; the very sacred principles
of ethical journalism.
Only
the pictures and images were outstanding. He had hired a flashy and dreadlocked
mannequin ‘Creative Director’ with zero media experience or knowledge and side-lined
the professional freelance photographer that was initially engaged for magazine
images. But it was taking Mr ‘Luxury’ forever to get the job done. He was an
overly ambitious, smooth-talking, I-know-it-all-and-should-lead-the-team kind
of guy. He understood Lanre’s self-centred language of luxury and elitism and
fully explored it to manipulate him to take some drastic decisions, including
his breakup with Lisa.
Chuks
(the guy’s name) said Lanre had handed over the project to him and he was
ecstatic about it. He told me Lanre said he (Chuks) was now ‘in-charge’ of the
project and could sack anyone he wanted. He said Lanre had been having private
meetings with him and told him he wanted to lay me off. I felt offended and
asked why. He was rambling on I ‘not being able to lead the team’ or ‘being
incompetent.’ How? What insult! Was the magazine not ready for the first issue,
from an editorial point? Were my stories watery and substandard? Like Lanre
when I confronted him (with due deference though), Chuks was incoherent.
True
to the assertion, Lanre cut off communication with me, and without a cogent
justification, gave off a body language that suggested he was done with me. All
of these were after I’d laid the foundation that none of them had the knowledge
or experience to do.
I
knew Lanre’s game plan. He (and his ilk) only sees people as tools; so Chuks blind
ambition was a perfect diversion and pawn until he’s filled and needs to go on
to the next meal. Chuks kept changing concepts and philosophies at will midway
through production and walking through a maze. He was what you might call inefficiently
busy (maybe eye service or in Warri lingua, ‘forming activity’). The team was groping in the dark. They had no
idea. It was three months and the debut issue was not out, except my team’s
editorial contents that were 100 percent complete. Where in the world does a
greenhorn photographer-turned-Creative-director-overnight lead a magazine
project? Without a single previous experience? It was a cul-de-sac!
Laughably,
they want to build the fantasy magazine on the stories my team and I had
painstakingly researched and written. But I have my aces up my sleeve. I’ll
come to that later. On behalf of his future victims, I want to change Lanre’s (and
his ilk) skewed and twisted use-and-dump immoral business beliefs and gimmicks.
But
I digress. Back to Lanre’s merry-go-round ‘luxury’ magazine house. Sneakily, he
blamed the editorial unit still for the delays. ‘How, sir?’ I asked him
exasperatedly. But he kept prevaricating. How dumb did he think everybody was!
If he thinks he could buy people’s voice and opinion and maybe love, I wonder
what makes him think integrity, intelligence and grit are for sale too.
He
had obviously schooled Lisa on what he wanted – of course without the
underlying motives – and she was already playing the tunes he dictated while
putting on a flaky bold face. Classic Lisa! Even when it seems she finally has
an opinion of her own, it’s always shaded by Lanre’s ego-fuelled preferences
and biases which often border on his crave for a God-like reverence and being
ensconced in his little elitist burble world. God help you if Lisa agrees with
you on a matter in private and Lanre has a differing opinion later. She’ll deny
you flatly.
The lies you didn’t know
She
was back on the project and they were suspending the editorial unit, she
announced to me in Lanre’s presence. Rather than being miffed, I was amused and
felt pity for this stunted project. In the weeks Lisa went missing, Chuks had
suggested to Lanre that to publish a ‘luxury magazine for upper class
citizens,’ as they myopically re-termed it midway, he doesn’t need the
editorial unit on full-time (Huh? Tell me about it. Definitely, another world
first!).
Not
surprisingly, Lisa did a volte-face and agreed – a sharp contrast to our
discussions on phone when she was away on protest, long before it became
public.
“I
know there’s a problem. You’ve not been in the office for two weeks now. Please
what’s happening?” I had enquired.
“It’s
a very deep problem, Kelvin. Chuks wanted pictures of naked girls in the
magazine and Lanre is on the same page with him, but I don’t want to be part of
any of that. He told Lanre to remove me as publisher and face of the magazine and
that the magazine project can go on without me, and would you imagine Lanre agreed?
He’s changing the magazine at will and spiritually manipulating Lanre. Chuks is
illuminati. He’s evil and God will scatter them.”
“But I don’t understand why Mr. Lanre has
stopped communicating with me. Does he have any complaints about my work?” I
asked, deliberately sidestepping the rash of issues she raised.
“No.
Your writings are standard and OK for any standard magazine anywhere,” she
replied in measured tones. She paused and then asked, “Are they still planning
to use my name as the title of the magazine?”
“I
can’t say categorically; Mr. Lanre doesn’t talk with me much. But Monalisa’s
still the name on the template.”
‘’I
can’t allow them use the name I built as a brand over the years. How can I take
it back?”
“Just
get it registered with the Copyright Commission and the National Library. And
if they still go ahead to publish the magazine with the name, you can report
them and the government agencies will take it from there.” I shrugged and
paused. I didn’t want to be part of this any longer. It was clear too many
things were wrong at once. “But I didn’t bargain for all these…” I complained.
“I’m
sooo sorry, Kelvin. I’m really sorry about how everything turned out…” Her
voice was tired.
“What
are you going to do now?”
“I
just want to leave the country to clear my head. Later, I’ll work on my
project, a tv talk show.”
“Great.
Although I wished you guys would reconcile; it would be great for the magazine.
You’re the brand they wanted to leverage on. Most new magazines don’t last
beyond a lifespan of six months because certain key elements are missing.”
“No;
I’m not coming back. It’s a deep spiritual problem.”
Two
weeks later, Lisa was back and giving her nod to Lanre’s baseless grudge against
me. But that was OK; the atmosphere was suffocating already. One week later, I
sent Lanre an SMS requesting for my salary and that I had other engagements
that wouldn’t allow me frequent visit to his office to recover his debt to me. He
felt offended. “I advice (sic) that all communication from you should be in
writing and directed to the company, please do not use this channel to reach me
again,” his reply read in part. I sensed the Nigerian typical case of social
class bullying.
It’s half time whistle
Piqued,
I called Lisa to complain. But she told me to stop calling her too. She told me
she was with him when my message came into his phone. “I don’t even know why
I’m dignifying you with a response,” she added cheekily. Such a cocky
submission from Madam ‘Celebrity’ and ‘Superior.’ But I knew that attitude: the tame voice of Jacob and the wild,
arrogant hand of Esau – as always.
Well,
I have a piece of advice for them too:
THEY SHOULDN’T BOTHER PUBLISHING THE MAGAZINE WITH THE STORIES IN THE TEMPLATE
ALL OF WHICH I EDITED, EXCEPT THEY DON’T MIND PUBLISHING STALE ARTICLES. Rather,
Lanre should tell whichever ‘editor’ he plans to name on the masthead to get a
new set of writers write new stories for his or her editing for the magazine. I
will never allow Lanre credit my intellectual work to another ‘editor.’ It’s a
promise because all the stories and articles are with me and I will publish
them online and in newspapers and magazines before his magazine goes to press.
Already
my lawyers have slammed them with a court notice over the monies they owe me.
Lanre (and Lisa too) probably thinks I’ll be cowered by the ‘might’ of his
wealth and high-powered connection. They also probably believe that as ‘upper
class citizens’ – as they have classified their stillborn magazine – I should
beg, grovel and lick their boots in exchange for the ‘favour’ of being given MY
OWN MONEY. But they fall into the common trap some people make when relating
with ‘unknown’ persons. Asides, an ‘unknown’ cannot be stereotyped.
Lanre
and Lisa have had their time in the sun to play, trampling at will on my right,
dignity and pride. But the half-time whistle has gone and it’s substitution
time. It’s my time to play on the field and I sooo want to score!
Get update via email
